Key Considerations and Insights on Advisory Board Compensation

The advisory board is as important as an experienced crew in a world that never stops moving when steering in open water. The advisory board gives strategic advice, industry expertise, and priceless networks. On the other hand, the compensation is a way to incentivize and bond the advisor with the task. We are going to take a deep look at and focus on the most human elements of startup advisor and board of advisors compensation in this article, with insights and advice backed by data.

Types of Compensation for Advisory Boards

Compensating advisory board members is a critical aspect of startup governance, ensuring alignment of interests and fostering strategic guidance. Typically, startup advisor compensation comprises a combination of equity and, in some cases, cash payments. The choice between these compensation methods depends on various factors such as the startup’s lifecycle stage, cash flow situation, and the advisor’s preferences. Let’s delve into the types of compensation for advisory boards in detail:

Equity

Equity is a prevalent form of compensation for advisors in startups, aligning their interests with the company’s long-term success. Here are key details about equity compensation:

• Percentage Range: Equity percentages for advisors can vary widely but commonly range between 0.1% to 1% of the company’s equity.
• Vesting Schedule: Equity grants for advisors are typically vested over a period of two to four years, with a one-year cliff. This means that advisors must serve for at least one year before any equity vests, after which it vests gradually over the remaining vesting period.
• Alignment of Interests: By offering equity, startups incentivize advisors to contribute their expertise and networks towards the company’s growth, as their compensation is directly tied to the company’s performance.

Cash

While equity is the primary form of compensation for startup advisors, cash payments may also be offered, particularly in more established startups with positive cash flow. Here’s what you need to know about cash compensation:

• Hourly Basis or Fixed Deliverables: Cash compensation for advisors can be structured on an hourly basis or fixed for specific deliverables or projects. Hourly rates are negotiated based on the advisor’s expertise and time commitment, while fixed payments are agreed upon for delivering tangible outcomes or milestones.
• Supplementary to Equity: Cash compensation is often used as a supplementary form of compensation in addition to equity, especially for advisors who prefer immediate financial rewards or for startups with limited equity to offer.
• Flexibility and Immediate Benefit: Unlike equity, which is subject to vesting schedules, cash payments provide advisors with immediate financial benefits for their contributions, making them attractive, particularly for advisors who prefer liquidity or have short-term commitments.

What is an Advisory Share?

An advisory share represents a portion of the company’s equity that is set aside and allocated exclusively for members of the advisory board. It serves as a tangible expression of the company’s appreciation for the guidance, expertise, and support provided by these advisors. Advisory shares are typically granted as a form of compensation for the advisory board’s strategic input, industry insights, and valuable connections.

Purpose

The primary purpose of advisory shares is to align the interests of advisors with those of the startup, fostering a collaborative relationship and incentivizing long-term commitment. By offering equity ownership, startups provide advisors with a stake in the company’s success, motivating them to actively contribute their expertise and networks to drive growth and value creation.

Structure

Advisory shares are subject to specific terms and conditions, including vesting schedules, which dictate when advisors become entitled to ownership of the equity. The structure of advisory shares typically includes the following elements:

• Equity Allocation: The company allocates a predetermined percentage of its equity to be designated as advisory shares, which are reserved exclusively for advisors.
• Vesting Schedule: Advisory shares are subject to vesting schedules, requiring advisors to fulfill certain conditions, such as remaining actively engaged with the company for a specified period, before fully owning the equity. Vesting schedules often include a “cliff period,” during which no equity vests, followed by gradual vesting over subsequent periods.
• Acceleration Provisions: In some cases, acceleration provisions may be included in advisory share agreements, allowing for the acceleration of equity vesting under certain circumstances, such as a change of control or termination without cause.

Key Considerations

When implementing advisory shares, startups should consider various factors to ensure the effectiveness and fairness of the equity compensation arrangement. Key considerations include:

• Advisor Selection: Careful selection of advisors is essential to ensure that advisory shares are awarded to individuals who bring relevant expertise, industry knowledge, and networks to the table.
• Equity Percentage: Determining the appropriate percentage of equity to allocate as advisory shares requires balancing the value of the advisor’s contributions with the company’s overall equity structure and ownership interests.
• Vesting Terms: Designing a fair and reasonable vesting schedule is crucial to incentivize advisor engagement while aligning with the company’s growth trajectory and fundraising milestones.
• Legal and Tax Implications: Startups should seek legal and tax advice to ensure compliance with relevant regulations and tax implications associated with granting advisory shares.

Important Factors in Advisory Board Compensation

When determining the appropriate compensation for an advisory board, several factors should be considered:

Expertise and Stature of the Advisor

The expertise, industry experience, and professional stature of the advisor are significant determinants of their compensation. Advisors with extensive experience, specialized knowledge, or influential networks may command higher compensation due to the value they bring to the table. Factors to consider include:

• Relevant Experience: Advisors with direct experience in the startup’s industry or sector, as well as specific skills or expertise relevant to the company’s needs, are likely to be highly valued and may warrant higher compensation.
• Industry Reputation: Advisors with a strong reputation, established track record of success, or notable achievements in their field may demand higher compensation, reflecting the perceived value of their insights and connections.
• Networks and Connections: Advisors who can provide strategic introductions, access to key industry players, or valuable networking opportunities may be compensated at a premium, as their connections can significantly impact the startup’s growth trajectory.

Level of Involvement

The level of involvement and engagement of the advisor in the startup’s affairs is another crucial factor in determining compensation. Advisors who play more active roles, providing ongoing strategic guidance, hands-on support, or frequent consulting services, may require higher compensation to reflect their time and effort commitment. Considerations include:

• Consulting Frequency: Advisors who engage in regular consulting sessions, attend board meetings, or provide continuous support and mentorship may justify higher compensation to compensate for their ongoing involvement and contributions.
• Strategic Contributions: Advisors who actively participate in strategic decision-making, offer valuable insights, and help drive key initiatives forward may be entitled to greater compensation, reflecting the impact of their contributions on the company’s success.
• Introductions and Connections: Advisors who facilitate strategic introductions, partnerships, or business opportunities that directly benefit the company may merit higher compensation, as their active involvement generates tangible value for the startup.

Company Stage

The stage of the company’s development, particularly its growth trajectory and funding status, influences the type and level of compensation offered to advisory board members. Considerations include:

• Early-Stage vs. Mature Startups: Early-stage startups often rely more heavily on equity compensation to attract and retain advisors, as they may have limited cash resources and higher risk profiles. In contrast, mature startups or companies with stable revenue streams may offer a combination of equity and cash compensation, reflecting their financial stability and growth potential.
• Equity Percentage: Early-stage startups may offer higher equity percentages to compensate for the higher risk associated with their stage of development. Advisors may be willing to accept lower cash compensation in exchange for a larger equity stake, aligning their interests with the company’s long-term success and growth prospects.

Data And Benchmarks To Consider

When determining advisory board compensation, startups can benefit from referencing industry data and benchmarks to ensure that their compensation packages are competitive and aligned with market standards. Here are key data points and benchmarks to consider:

Startup Compensation Report

The 2020 Startup Compensation Report provides valuable insights into the compensation practices for advisory board members in early-stage companies. According to the report:

• Equity Allocation: Advisory board members typically receive between 0.05% and 0.5% of equity in early-stage startups. This range serves as a benchmark for startups to gauge the appropriate percentage of equity to allocate to advisory board members based on their contributions and the company’s stage of development.
• Equity Percentage: The equity percentage granted to advisory board members may vary depending on factors such as the advisor’s expertise, level of involvement, and industry reputation. Startups can use this data to inform their decision-making process and ensure that their equity grants are competitive and attractive to potential advisors.

Growth-Driven Compensation

Advisory board compensation is often tied to the company’s growth trajectory and financial performance. As the company progresses and achieves key milestones, advisory board compensation may transition into higher cash-based remuneration schemes. Key considerations include:

• Company Growth: Startups experiencing rapid growth and scaling operations may increase advisory board compensation to reflect the increased value and complexity of their business. This may include higher cash retainers, performance-based bonuses, or other forms of cash incentives.
• Cash-Based Remuneration: Cash-based compensation schemes, such as retainer fees, consulting fees, or project-based payments, may become more prevalent as startups mature and generate revenue. These cash incentives provide immediate financial rewards to advisory board members and may supplement or replace equity-based compensation over time.

Market Comparisons

In addition to industry reports and benchmarks, startups should conduct market comparisons to assess the competitiveness of their advisory board compensation packages. Factors to consider include:

• Industry Standards: Comparing advisory board compensation practices across similar companies within the industry can help startups benchmark their compensation packages and ensure that they are competitive in attracting top talent.
• Geographical Considerations: Regional differences in compensation practices and cost of living may influence advisory board compensation levels. Startups should take into account the geographical location of their advisors and adjust compensation packages accordingly.

Customization and Flexibility

While industry data and benchmarks provide valuable guidelines, startups should also customize their advisory board compensation packages to suit their unique needs, goals, and financial constraints. Key considerations include:

• Advisor Preferences: Understanding the preferences and expectations of potential advisors is essential for designing compensation packages that are attractive and mutually beneficial. Startups should engage in open dialogue with advisors to negotiate compensation terms that align with both parties’ interests.
• Equity vs. Cash: Balancing equity and cash compensation is crucial for startups, particularly in early-stage companies with limited resources. By offering a mix of equity and cash incentives, startups can attract and retain advisors while preserving financial flexibility and optimizing equity dilution.

Best Practices for Structuring Advisory Board Compensation

Implementing a well-structured compensation package is essential for attracting and retaining high-caliber advisory board members who can provide valuable guidance and support to startups. By adhering to best practices in compensation structuring, startups can ensure fairness, transparency, and alignment of interests. Here are some key best practices to consider:

• Clear Expectations: Define clear roles and expectations for advisory board members. This helps in quantifying their contributions and aligning compensation.
• Competitive Benchmarking: Stay informed about industry standards for advisory board compensation to offer competitive packages.
• Regular Reviews: Re-evaluate compensation packages regularly to reflect the advisor’s ongoing contribution and market changes.

Conclusion

Effective management of startup advisor compensation and board of advisors compensation is a critical component of a startup’s strategic development. By understanding the nuances of advisory board compensation and implementing best practices, startups can ensure they attract top-tier talent to guide them towards success. As the startup landscape evolves, so too should the strategies for compensating those who steer its progress.

FAQ